According to a recollection by Gibson William Harris, a former law clerk of Abraham Lincoln and William Herdon, Lincoln borrowed a copy of the works of Lord Byron from a schoolmaster in Albion, IL in “mid-autumn.” Lincoln, a Whig at the time, and Isaac P. Walker, a Democrat, were holding a debate there. Harris’s story indicated that Lincoln sought out a copy because he planned to use lines from the beginning of Byron’s poem “Lara, A Tale” in his opening statement.
*
By Abraham Lincoln’s time, slavery had so thoroughly immersed itself into American life that a robust “pro-slavery theology” had developed in some religious circles claiming the Bible justified enslaving African Americans on racial and evangelical grounds. As a sort of “opposition research,” Lincoln seems to have read one of the central texts of this theology—Rev. Frederick A. Ross’s Slavery Ordained by God—soon after its 1857 publication. Outraged by what he read, in October 1858 Lincoln wrote what appears to be an unpublished attack on Ross and his beliefs. After musing on the pretzel-logic such a theology required, Lincoln sarcastically declared: “But, slavery is good for some people!!! As a good thing, slavery is strikingly peculiar, in this, that it is the only good thing which no man ever seeks the good of, for himself. Nonsense! Wolves devouring lambs, not because it is good for their own greedy maws, but because it [is] good for the lambs!!!”
*
In October 1861, Abraham Lincoln reportedly read, The Rejected Stone: or Insurrection vs. Resurrection in America, by Moncure D. Conway. Conway was an abolitionist minister though he was descended from slave-holding First Families of Virginia and Maryland, including one of the signers of the Declaration of Independence from Maryland. Massachusetts Senator Charles Sumner gave Lincoln the book. [Link to book from google books]
Also this month in 1861, Lincoln read a dispatch announcing the death of his close friend, Colonel Edward D. Baker, namesake for the Lincolns’ son Edward “Eddy” Baker Lincoln, who had died over a decade earlier at the age of three.
*
According to John Hay, one of President Lincoln’s secretaries, on the night of October 11, 1864, he accompanied Lincoln to the War Department to wait for election returns. Hay reported that while waiting, Abraham Lincoln read several chapters of The Nasby Papers, a book of humorous writing by journalist and political commentator David R. Locke under the pen name, “Petroleum V. Nasby.” The fictional Nasby was a Copperhead or “Peace” Democrat.
While political commentary in America remains heated, one popular form of it that’s dropped away is the anonymous caricature. 19th century newspapers frequently published columns by fictional writers, often to ironically skewer an opposing political movement. Abraham Lincoln himself dabbled in this kind of writing but was mostly just a fan, and his favorite was Petroleum V. Nasby.
The creation of David R. Locke, Nasby was a bloviating Northern Democrat who supported the Confederacy. With biting wit, Locke made Nasby as repellant as possible—exposing the hypocrisy, ignorance, and racism of the secessionist cause. Locke’s humor and politics aligned with Lincoln’s and there are numerous stories of the president reading Nasby or even reciting pieces in meetings. For instance, when waiting for early election returns in the War Department Telegraph Office on October 11, 1864, Lincoln read some Nasby with John Hay to ease the tension.